Food intolerance as a cause of irritable bowel syndrome
Twenty-one patients with irritable bowel syndrome followed a strict elimination diet, consisting of a single meat, a single fruit, and distilled or spring water, for one week. Symptoms disappeared in 14 of the 21 patients. Subsequently, individual food challenges identified the following symptom-evoking foods (number of cases in parentheses): wheat (9), corn (5), dairy products (4), coffee (4), tea (3), citrus fruits (2). Jejunal biopsies were normal in all nine cases of wheat intolerance, indicating the patients did not have celiac disease. Six patients underwent food challenges in double-blind fashion through a nasogastric tube; the food intolerance was confirmed in each case. Changes in plasma levels of histamine, immune complexes, and eosinophils were similar after challenge with offending foods and control foods, indicating that these food intolerances were probably not immunologically mediated. In contrast, rectal prostaglandin E2 levels increased significantly after challenge with symptom-evoking foods, but only among patients whose gastrointestinal symptoms included diarrhea.
Comment: This study demonstrates that food intolerance is a major factor in the pathogenesis of irritable bowel syndrome. The reactions to foods may be mediated in part by prostaglandins, but an immunological mechanism does not appear to be involved. Consequently, the term "intolerance" would be preferable to "allergy," when describing food-induced symptoms in patients with irritable bowel syndrome. That distinction is not just academic, because one would not expect food-allergy testing to provide reliable results when the problem is not immunologically mediated. At present, an elimination diet followed by individual food challenges seems to be the most reliable method of identifying food intolerance.
Jones VA, et al. Food intolerance: a major factor in the pathogenesis of irritable bowel syndrome. Lancet 1982;2:1115-1117.
